An amended bill under consideration by the state
legislature could create problems for Loudon County in
its ongoing dispute with the Tellico Village Property
Owners Association over hundreds of delinquent
properties.
House Bill 2343, and its counterpart Senate Bill 1949, authorize a county to set aside an effort to take ownership of properties delinquent on taxes if the environmental and financial risks outweigh the value.
Per HB2343, a county mayor will have 90 to 120 days
to evaluate a property to determine if it fits as an
environmental and financial risk, and a county
legislative body can file a petition for relief of
the property in chancery court.
Senate Bill 54, which passed in 2014 and was
sponsored by Sen. Randy McNally, R-Oak Ridge,
allowed “a tax entity, when acquiring undeveloped or
unimproved property at a tax sale, to transfer such
property to a non-governmental entity for the
purpose of satisfying in full any fees assessed by
the non-governmental entity, as approved and
negotiated by both entities.”
Commissioner Van Shaver said changes in wording with
the current proposal could “completely preclude it
helping us in any shape, form or fashion.”
“They used the word ‘and’ instead of ‘or’, and I
know this sounds like a lot of hairsplitting but if
you’ll run that sentence through your mind you’ll
understand why that wouldn’t work with for us,”
Shaver said. “It would say that if we got 500 POA
lots, we could set them aside if it would create an
environmental problem and a financial problem. Well
that would preclude Tellico Village lots, they’re
not going to have environmental problems. The
initial language was that it would be environmental
problems or a financial burden for the county.”
Shaver said an amendment made to the Senate version
also added a sentence saying POA fees and dues could
not be considered in determining whether they were a
“financial obligation” to the county.
Per the bill, “any dues and assessments established
through covenants and restrictions shall not be
considered as part of the financial risks to be
considered.”
“I think what it was, I think the person that
represents the HOAs saw an opportunity to slide a
sentence in there that would basically null and void
the bill that (state Rep. Jimmy) Matlock (R-Lenoir
City) and McNally passed two years ago,” state Rep.
Kent Calfee, R-Kingston, said.
Calfee said the bill proposed two years ago
stipulated that if a county took possession of
property it would not have to pay POA fees. The
amendment would potentially change that.
“We just can’t have that, and so we talked back and
forth on the phone to Buddy Bradshaw and Van and
Steve Harrelson and our people in Roane County and
it just got totally out of hand, and we have a
meeting Wednesday with the mayor from Roane, Loudon
and Monroe counties, and we’re going to try to
resolve this,” Calfee said Monday. “If not, I’m
going to run the bill, I’ve amended it to take the
line out that got put in the Senate because that’d
be detrimental to Loudon County.”
Loudon County Mayor Rollen “Buddy” Bradshaw was
scheduled to testify in Nashville on Feb. 24, but
the bill was delayed until March 2. Bradshaw is
expected to answer questions from the State and
Local Government Committee.
A “conservative” estimate on Tellico Village POA
assessment dues owed on delinquent lots is “upwards
of $500,000,” noting the expenditure would be
reoccurring.
“We’ve got so many communities that have the POA
groups, that could get close to $1 million annually
pretty quickly,” Bradshaw said. “... As long as they
were in the county’s possession, the county would be
responsible for paying those POA dues.”
Matlock said he believed the amendment would fail.
If the House and Senate have different versions of
the bill, it will go to conference.
“We’re in an unusual situation in Loudon County,”
Matlock said. “What helps Tellico Village harms the
county. What harms the county helps Tellico Village.
So, we’re trying to come up with some kind of
arrangement. ... The bill was actually — we don’t
want the bill hijacked because it was something that
Calfee needed for his community, and it’s unfair
that somebody jumped in there and tried put
something on it.”
Calfee introduced the bill because of a situation in
Roane County where a burned building that “may” have
been valued at $15,000 cost the county $600,000 to
tear down. If the bill doesn’t revert back to its
original state, Calfee said he would retract it.
Village POA reacts
A statement issued Friday by the POA said Tellico
Village officials were “surprised” to learn of the
county’s legislative actions because “the
association has been offering for over a year to
take back any Tellico Village lots that the county
might end up with as a result of the delinquent tax
sale.” Despite this offering, the statement says the
county has not responded to the POA’s proposed
agreement to take back the lots.
Per the release, the POA offered the county a
settlement in January 2015 to accept any delinquent
lots that initially revert back to the county.
“However, rather than responding, Loudon County has
now elected to support the current legislation,” the
release said.
The release notes the POA is “concerned” that
current legislation doesn’t address the future
disposition of tax sale properties, which could be
considered “contrary to the long-term financial
interests of both the county and the association.”
“However, the proposed legislation completely fails
to include a mechanism to get these lots back into
the hands of third-parties that would pay both taxes
and assessments in the future,” the release
continues. “These hundreds of Tellico Village lots
would ultimately be rendered unmarketable because
the tax liens on the property would continue to
increase exponentially with no end in sight. This
short-sighted process could ultimately deprive both
Loudon County and the association of millions of
dollars of tax and assessment revenue over the next
decade.”
John Cherry, POA public relations manager, said
Village property owners provide about $7.4 million
in annual taxes in the county. Dues from about 405
lots would amount to $571,536 based off the POA’s
current assessment fee of $117.60.
According to the release, the POA thinks a “minor
clarification” is needed in order to explain what
happens to a title and tax liens on a property
should the county withdraw its bid on a property in
a tax sale.
“The association has been trying to work through the
legislative process to include this minor
clarification to the legislation in order to
preserve the marketability of these lots in the
future,” according to the release. “Alternatively,
the association remains committed to its prior offer
to Loudon County to assume responsibility for these
Tellico Village lots after the tax sale, which would
make the new legislation unnecessary.”