Tennessee lawmakers have elevated hatred for
government and disgust for poor people to an art
form.
alternet.org-If you're worried about where America
is heading, look no further than Tennessee. Its lush
mountains and verdant rolling countryside belie a
mean-spirited public policy that only makes sense if
you believe deeply in the anti-collectivist,
anti-altruist philosophy of Ayn Rand. It's what you
get when you combine hatred for government with
disgust for poor people.
Tennessee starves what little government it has,
ranking dead last in per capita tax revenue. To fund
its minimalist public sector, it makes sure that
low-income residents pay as much as possible through
heavily regressive sales taxes, which rank 10th
highest among all states as a percent of total tax
revenues.
As you would expect, this translates into hard
times for its public school systems, which rank 48th
in school revenues per student and 45th in teacher
salaries. The failure to invest in education also
corresponds with poverty: the state has the 40th
worst poverty rate (15%) and the 13th highest state
percentage of poor children (26%).
Employment opportunities also are extremely poor
for the poor. Only 25% have full-time jobs, 45% are
employed part-time, and a whopping 30% have no jobs
at all.
So what do you do with all those low-income folks
who don't have decent jobs? You put a good number of
them in jail. In fact, only Louisiana, Georgia and
New Mexico have higher jail incarceration rates.
From the perspective of Tennessee legislators,
it's all about providing the proper incentives to
motivate the poor. For starters, you make sure that
no one could possible live on welfare payments (TANF:
Temporary Assistance to Needy Families). Although
President Clinton's welfare reform program curtailed
how long a family can receive welfare (60 months)
and dramatically increased the work requirements,
Tennessee set the maximum family welfare payment at
only $185 per month. (That's how much a top hedge
fund manager makes in under one second.) As a
result, the Volunteer State ranks 49th in TANF, just
above Mississippi ($170).
Kick 'em when they're down or tough love?
In the Randian universe, it's not enough to
starve public education and the poor. You also must
blame the poor both for their poverty and for the
crumbling educational system. If a poor child is
failing it must be the fault of low-income parents.
So how do you drive the point home? You take away
their welfare checks if their kids don't do well in
school, which is precisely what the Tennessee House
and Senate are about to do. The KnoxvilleNews.com
reports:
The bill is sponsored by Sen. Stacey
Campfield, R-Knoxville, and Rep. Vance Dennis,
R-Savannah. It calls for a 30 percent reduction
in Temporary Assistance for Needy Families
benefits to parents whose children are not
making satisfactory progress in school.
More amazing still, the bill originally applied
to all children of TANF parents, even if they were
severely disabled. Realizing that they had gone too
far, the bill was amended so that, "it would not
apply when a child has a handicap or learning
disability or when the parent takes steps to try
improving the youngster’s school performance — such
as signing up for a parenting class, arranging a
tutoring program or attending a parent-teacher
conference." (Imagine the uproar if those provision
were applied to upper-income parents, assuming any
still use the public school system.)
Dennis told the House Health Subcommittee the
measure now only applies to “parents who do
nothing.” He described the measure as “a carrot and
stick approach.”